

Finally, since I definitely signed up a long time ago....
Not that much has been written by Western journalists about Eritrea. Michaela Wrong decided to write all of it. While I thought her tome "I didn't do it for you: How the West betrayed a small African nation," was interesting and informative, it was way too long - like a Horn of Africa marathon that never ended.
Parts of it were fascinating, especially the chapter on Kagnew, an American military base just outside the capital Asmara. Wrong shows just how bad Americans in other parts of the world can be, from innocuous farting contests to children born to an Eritrean prostitutes and American fathers who could not be identified and would never take responsibility for their well-being.
Perhaps more books aren't written about the Horn because the level of government surveillance and disruption there functions as an effective deterrent. (But then again, that also applies to other countries that have lots of books written about them.)
I'm glad Wrong wrote this book because I'm glad to have it on my shelf as a reference and now have a better baseline of knowledge, yet I wish I could recommend it more whole-heatedly as there are so few alternatives.
Anyone else know of better books on Eritrea? Let me know.
Tuesday, August 26, 2008
African Reading Challenge 2008: I didn't do it for you
Posted by
Scarlett Lion
at
1:50 PM
Labels: Books, Non-UG African Country
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)



5 comments:
"Towards Asmara" by Thomas Keneally is a fictionalized, but good story of the Eritrea-Ethiopia conflict. It is historically accurate, although the facts are certainly embellished.
Although the 'heroes' are foreigners, I was ready to overlook that and I enjoyed it. Wanna trade?
There really is no better book on Eritrea --- and if you haven't already, you should read Michela Wrong's other book: "In the Footsteps of Mr. Kurtz: Living on the Brink of Disaster in the Congo"
@tumwijuke: You got a deal.
@anonymous: I have read that book and did indeed like it more. I read it right after "King Leopold's Ghost," which covers a different period of time, of course, though it did kind of make me wish Hochschild had written a book on modern Congo as well.
@everyone: I forgot to mention the wonders of Evelyn Waugh's book Scoop, which isn't about Eritrea per say, but is really wonderful, and I promise a blog post on it sometime soon.
My Eritrean friend strongly disliked "I didn't do it for you"---she recommended "From Guerrillas To Government: Eritrean People'S Liberation Front (Eastern African Studies)" by David Pool. She did mention it was kind of a dry read.
I've read ALOT about the history of the Horn of Africa, and in my humble opinion, Wrong does this country's history more justice than anything else I've read.
Regarding the DRC, In the Footsteps of Mr. Kurtz is only surpassed by the horrifying King Leopold's Ghost.
Post a Comment